These Amazon Beauty Products Have Near-Perfect Star Ratings And More Than 100,000 Reviews

One thing about me? I’m going to read the reviews. Before I purchase anything — especially beauty products that will be applied to my face or body — I want to ensure I’m not wasting money on a mysterious bottle or tube that no one else can vouch for, and I suspect many other shoppers feel the same way.

That is why it is always a pleasure to discover those rare skincare, hair, nail, or makeup products that have garnered over 100,000 reviews while maintaining an average rating of more than four stars. I view that as a strong indicator of reliability, and I have made it a habit to track items that reach this milestone. Below, I have compiled them so you can explore these trustworthy options for yourself.

From drugstore staples to TikTok favorites that actually deliver, here are the beauty products everyone is raving about — so don’t miss out.

BS-Mall 14-piece makeup brush set

Rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars across 130,939 reviews

Fourteen makeup brushes for as low as $10 (depending on which of the seven color options you select) is an incredible value. The set includes five large face brushes and nine smaller ones for everything from concealer to eyeshadow to lips, including a double-sided eyebrow brush with a spoolie. These brushes are vegan and crafted from synthetic fibers that are gentle on sensitive skin. This would also make a fantastic gift for the makeup enthusiast in your life.

Promising review: “I was in the market for new brushes and these were on sale and I do not regret purchasing. The bristles are nice and sturdy And wash up nice when cleaning. There’s no shedding At all like you get with cheap brushes. I have been using them for a few months and they have been holding up well especially for the price. I would totally recommend!”

Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser multi-use concealer

Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars across 215,085 reviews

This Maybelline concealer is easily one of the most popular makeup items I have ever encountered. Having nearly 150,000 perfect 5-star ratings is difficult to surpass. Infused with haloxyl for an anti-aging formula that minimizes the appearance of dark circles, this concealer is also highly versatile: you can even select shades lighter or darker than your usual tone to use for highlighting and contouring. Reviewers love its smoothness and blendability so much that it is a hill they are willing to die on. It is available in 18 shades, including two “brightener” and “neutralizer” options for color correcting.

Promising review: “I have been repurchasing this concealer for years. It holds up when it’s set, blends like a dream and looks skin-like. I will probably be buying this until the day I day because if I know anything at all, I know this is the concealer I want to be buried with on my face.”

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars across 119,446 reviews

I have been using Nyx’s Butter Gloss for nearly a decade and have no intention of stopping. It is pigmented yet wearable for daily use, comes in a variety of gorgeous colors, and features a smooth texture that feels wonderful on the lips. My personal favorites are the nude-pink Tiramisu or occasionally the bolder Red Velvet, but the clear Sugar Glass is the most popular and looks great on its own or layered over another lip color.

Promising review: “This lip gloss is my ride or die holy grail. I have almost all the colors. It’s so smooth and moisturizing, lasts a long time and I love the colors!!”

Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink liquid lipstick

Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars across 180,303 reviews

When it comes to liquid lipsticks that reviewers adore, Maybelline is a clear winner. The SuperStay Matte Ink liquid lipstick is an Amazon best seller, and one I can personally recommend: I wore it to a wedding and it not only looked fantastic in photos, but it also lasted all day without drying out my lips. It is available in a wide range of colors, from brights to neutrals. (P.S.: There is a $1.99 coupon you can apply at checkout.)

Promising review: “At this price, this is like finding the Holy Grail of long-lasting lipwear. It’s my everyday lipstick now. I have 4-5 colors and you can mix them for even more. You can get that overlined look without having to use liner or any other product, which is amazing. Just make sure you moisturize your lips at night after taking this off–it comes off easily with makeup remover or petroleum-based lip glosses, but nothing and I mean NOTHING else budges this stuff. I am already planning on buying more colors.” — E. James

Mielle Organics rosemary mint scalp and hair strengthening oil

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars across 122,539 reviews

We have previously featured the Mielle Organics Rosemary Mint Scalp and Hair Strengthening Oil, which went viral on TikTok for its reported ability to thicken and strengthen thinning hair. It contains more than 30 nutrients and essential oils that can help combat dandruff while working to protect, lengthen, and strengthen your hair.

This oil is suitable for all hair types and can be used daily or whenever you desire a more intensive hair treatment. You can also apply it to your split ends prior to shampooing for added nourishment.

Essence Lash Princess false lash effect mascara

Rating: 4.3 out of 5 stars across 386,018 reviews

If you enjoy the look of false lashes but dislike the sensation of wearing them, Essence’s Lash Princess False Lash Effect, which offers both lengthening and volumizing benefits, might be the perfect product for you. This mascara boasts an impressive 258,000+ 5-star ratings.

It features a straight conic fiber brush engineered to prevent the mascara from clumping or globbing on your lashes. It is also fragrance-, oil-, and cruelty-free, making it a great choice for those with sensitive eyes.

Schick Hydro Silk touch-up dermaplaning tools

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars across 197,873 reviews

Removing fine facial hairs can often feel tedious, but these Schick Hydro Silk facial razors simplify the process significantly. Designed for eyebrow shaping, dermaplaning, and quick touch-ups, they include a precision cover to ensure they are foolproof for trimming unwanted hair. Their portable size also makes them convenient for travel.

COLOR WOW Dream Coat Supernatural Spray

Rating: 4.3 out of 5 stars across 101,789 reviews

If you struggle with fly-aways and frizzy hair, you should try the Color Wow Dream Coat. This spray treatment essentially waterproofs your hair to keep it from frizzing in humid conditions. You simply spray it onto damp hair and blow-dry to achieve the full effect.

Promising review: “This product truly delivers on its promises! From the very first use, I noticed how my hair became smoother, shinier, and completely frizz-free, even on very humid days. I love that it doesn’t weigh my hair down or leave it greasy — it feels super lightweight with a professional, salon-like finish.”

Thayers alcohol-free rose petal and witch hazel facial toner

Rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars across 131,963 reviews

This gentle toner can improve skin texture, hydrate, and reduce the appearance of pores, among other benefits. It is soothing and non-irritating, thanks to an alcohol-free formula containing witch hazel, rose water, and aloe vera. Even if you have never incorporated toner into your skincare routine, reviewers who were once skeptical say this is the product that changed their minds.

Olaplex No. 3 Hair Perfector repairing hair treatment

Rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars across 147,923 reviews

Olaplex has established itself as a trusted hair care brand, and this pre-shampoo treatment for damaged and dry hair is just one of its many popular products. Intended for weekly use and suitable for all hair types, you can apply this to damp hair, leave it for up to 10 minutes, and rinse before shampooing as usual. The result is stronger, healthier hair that is less prone to breakage, according to the brand and those who have used it.

Promising review: “I have naturally curly hair, plus lots of breakage issues from health problems and this Olaplex 3 has really improved my hair, made it stronger & with less breakage. I use it 2X week and as with most things, it takes time to see good results, but even my hairdresser made the comment that my hair was lots better. And I’m so glad that there’s no scent to it as I’m extremely smell sensitive. This stuff has really helped, and I will continue to keep buying & using it.” — obarc

Neutrogena makeup remover wipes

Rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars across 113,859 reviews

I swear by these makeup wipes, and it seems the rest of the internet does as well. They are the top bestseller in the makeup cleansing wipes category and rank among the top beauty bestsellers overall. These wipes are effective, compostable, and gentle on the skin — they remove up to 99% of makeup, according to the brand. My face always feels clean and fresh after using a Neutrogena wipe, whether I am removing a full face of makeup or just clearing away oil and sunscreen.

Cuccio Naturale revitalizing cuticle oil

Rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars across 129,288 reviews

As you may know, cuticle oil is recommended by experts to strengthen nails, and this specific bottle is a favorite among reviewers. Cuccio’s non-greasy, fast-absorbing formula features vitamin E and natural oils for deep hydration. The oil is available in several scents, including a fragrance-free version, and the brand notes that one drop per nail is sufficient to revitalize your cuticles.

Promising review: “I’m 70 and have tried a hundred different oils, and lotions, nothing has ever helped my dry cuticles until now. I waited to use it for a few weeks to see if it worked, before reviewing it. It is the only product ever that’s improved my cuticles. I use it a few times a day, I’m so happy to find a product that works. No more cracked dried cuticles. I think it’s even helping my nails. It’s a big bottle and will last a long time. It’s a good value too.” — vikki

Hero Cosmetics Mighty Patch original pimple patches

Rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars across 165,452 reviews

Hero Cosmetics Mighty Patch pimple patches have remained at the top of Amazon’s bestseller list for quite some time. These patches are formulated with medical-grade hydrocolloid, a gel-forming material originally used for wound care that helps heal the skin.

The brand claims the patches can produce results in six to eight hours, a statement supported by multiple reviewers. They feature a matte, translucent finish and adhere securely to the skin, so you don’t have to worry about them coming off while you sleep.

Rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars across 138,238 reviews

If you haven’t joined the CeraVe fan club yet, now is the perfect time. The CeraVe Moisturizing Cream can be used on your hands, body, and face, making it an excellent, versatile option if you want to avoid buying multiple skincare products. It is noncomedogenic and contains hydrating ingredients like ceramides and hyaluronic acid. It is also rich yet gentle, having earned the National Eczema Association’s seal of acceptance.

Beetles gel nail polish in French White

Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars across 123,753 reviews

White nail polish is a year-round classic; you can apply a full coat or use it for nail art or a French manicure. This gel polish comes in a glossy white that can last at least three weeks, provided you apply it correctly with a top and base coat and cure it under an LED light. (These are sold separately, though you can purchase a set that includes the gel polish along with the top and base coats.) Reviewers note that it has a smooth consistency and is easy to apply. At only $7 a bottle, it could save you a significant amount on salon visits over time.

Promising review: “Thrilled with this gel polish! The application is smooth, and the color payoff is intense. What sets it apart is the durability – my manicure looks flawless for weeks without chipping or fading. The range of vibrant shades is impressive, and the glossy finish adds a professional touch. Say goodbye to frequent salon visits – this gel polish is a DIY dream come true! Highly recommend for a long-lasting, salon-quality manicure at home.”

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars across 133,855 reviews

If you use false eyelashes, you understand the importance of a quality lash glue that isn’t irritating or gloopy. That is what makes the Kiss strip lash adhesive such a standout for reviewers. The formula is latex-free, hypoallergenic, and odor-free, applying thinly and clearly with the included brush. Reviewers also appreciate the affordable price and the long-lasting hold.

Promising review: “My KISS lash glue is my holy grail. I will not use or buy any other lash glue. I am OBSESSED!It adheres so easily, it holds thru literally anything and everything, it’s cheap to buy and it doesn’t irritate the eye.”